! You are not logged in to Prodigits. Please register or login.

Religion&Beliefs Forum

From: haq
Subject: Compilation of QURAN
----------
@ haq - 5.11.11 - 12:04am
Khui in 'bayan' says that increases in Ali(ra)'s Quran were interpretations and increases in other mushafs should be taken as interpretations and not implicates of Quran .I think junaid mentioned Ibn Masud's Quran - this was different to Ali's this doesn't mean they had different Quranic stags or incomplete etc does it???Party 1) is Khui's camp and they said increases in Ali's Quran are interpretations and not actual ayahs (see above quote). Party 2) said they are actual ayahs in Ali's Quran thus claimed tehrif (as-sayrafi 'at-tahrif wat-tabdil'). Point is noone claimed them as tafsirs cos the concept of tafsir wasn't developed. Besides you in your extremism don't realise that even if they were tafsirs meant for the general Muslims then the need would be greater for a Quran exclusively containing solely t
9.02.12 - 09:11am
[reply]
[go to reply]
[go to topic]

8 Religion&Beliefs Forum
9 Forum Index

Custom Search