You are not logged in to Prodigits. Please register or login.

Subject: Umpire review system
Replies: 5 Views: 647

z45curse 30.12.10 - 08:34pm
Should be used across the spectrum. The icc must take charge and make it mandatory in all test matches for 24 odd months and an*lyse its accuracy thereafter and decide accordingly if it will improve the game and grey areas thereof .it should not be left up to teams to decide if they want to make use of the technology or not. Make it mandatory i say. * +

z45curse 30.12.10 - 08:39pm
Matches being won or lost on a dodgey umpiring call should be wiped out. We have the technology albeit in a still early and not fully proved or maybe understood or trusted stage. A step in the right direction is forward not back. * +

z45curse 30.12.10 - 08:46pm
And i see there is an existing post on this * +

the_mail 30.12.10 - 09:44pm
dont you south africans moan when you lose fs * +

the.trav 30.12.10 - 10:04pm
''z45curse 30.12.10 - 08:39pmMatches being won or lost on a dodgey umpiring call should be wiped out.'' Leaving it to the players to review a decision doesn't help to wipe out dodgy decisions. They use their two and are left to accept whatever decisions are made after. A 3rd party would be more effective in wiping out bad decisions instead of leaving it upto selfish players. * +

z45curse 31.12.10 - 03:15pm
3 reviews. If the reviews are used wisely then they wont be wasted. If selfish players call for a senseless review well then its up to the captain, coach etc to deal with the player. But you cant have some teams use it and others not. Either use it for all or scr*p it. I'd like to see it being used. *

+ refresh
+ my page
+ functions
3 search
4 submit a reply
+ bookmark
8 Sports Forum
9 Forum Index

Custom Search