You are not logged in to Prodigits. Please register or login.

Subject: Asad Shah

kimjongl 19.03.19 - 03:32pm
What was their motive? * +

recurve16 19.03.19 - 03:53pm
Official court transcripts...

In my view two essential questions have to be asked - why was this poor man killed and why was he killed in such an appalling fashion?

We may never know, however I did note in the course of the trial, that it seemed to be implied that the deceased might have been an abusive husband. I now see from the social work report, Saima Hayat, that you specifically allege he was abusive towards you.

You also allege, for the first time, that, before the killing of your husband, you were struck by him on the head with a hammer and knocked unconscious, as a result of which you were unable to take any part in the killing. That is indeed an interesting account, having regard to fact that there was no medical evidence from the doctors who examined you at the hospital that you suffered any injury whatsoever.

Having regard to the multiplicity of lies and concocted accounts which all three of you have made in this case and at different times, I would have considerable difficulty believing anything any of you now claim or have claimed in the past. From the evidence I have heard in this case I am satisfied that you Saima Hayat were the abusive partner in this relationship and not your husband. The evidence disclosed that you are a manipulative, scheming woman.

You and your co-accused plotted and planned to get rid of your husband, the father of your five children.

Mr Rauf may well have been the main assailant but all three of you are responsible for what was a merciless attack on Mr Hayat and all three of you are equally responsible for his death.

Mrs Abid and Mrs Hayat, you were also convicted of an attempt to pervert the course of justice by trying to cover up your crime in various ways all as libelled in that charge.

What I have observed throughout this trial is that none of you has any genuine remorse whatsoever for what you did.

You Mohammed Rauf gave evidence and you appeared to think you were fully enti * +

recurve16 19.03.19 - 07:35pm
Just noticed it had cut short for some reason...

You Mohammed Rauf gave evidence and you appeared to think you were fully entitled to do what you did. You too attempted to blacken the character of the deceased, based partly, it appears, on an account from the deceaseds wife, a proven liar, and, as I have commented before, having regard to the obvious lies told in this case, including by you Mr Rauf, it would be difficult to believe anything you say.

In your case Shahida Abid you even applauded the learned advocate depute, in what appeared to be a mocking fashion, after he had concluded his address.

In my view, in this case no genuine remorse has been expressed and none displayed by any of you.

* +

sisfreak2017 19.03.19 - 08:14pm
c*nts , behaving like what's the Normal back in whatever land. *

+ refresh
+ go to page 1-22
+ my page
+ functions
3 search
4 submit a reply
6 first page
+ bookmark
8 General Chat Forum
9 Forum Index

Custom Search